Get up to $45 in FREE Postage at Stamps.com use code COUPON1. expires 12/31/12

401(k) Match Day

bag of moneyI was catching up on some of the blogs I follow, and a post over at Thousandaire caught my eye. The post was titled “401k Match Day is like a Holiday.” I had a few immediate reactions to the post:

  1. I have lots of friends who are finishing up medical school, so “Match Day” means something else to me.
  2. I hate that my company has a 401(k) Match Day.
  3. Wait– other companies do 401(k) matching in a once-yearly lump sum too?!?!?
  4. 401(k) Match Day is like getting a tax refund. I’ve been meaning to write about how I hate tax refunds too, I should probably write something.

My biggest shock was that I am not alone in receiving my 401(k) match once a year. I thought my company was the only crazy one to go against the grain and do a once-yearly 401(k) match. I am not alone! But unlike Kevin over at Thousandaire, I do not jump for joy when that one day per year rolls around. Don’t get me wrong, I like getting free money, and seeing it appear all at once is pretty exciting, but the problem is: I would rather they add the match with every paycheck!

The reason I want my match every month is because I want to start earning interest on it immediately. I receive my 401(k) match every January for the previous year. So while it’s nice that my employer increased the 2013 match (to a number still so small it’s almost offensive), I won’t see that match until 2014! That’s a whole year of investment gains I’m missing out on and my company gets to enjoy for itself.

It’s for the same reason I hate getting a tax refund. If I withhold too much money from my paycheck for taxes, that means I haven’t been earning interest on that money. As many people put it, if you get a big tax refund, it means you gave an interest-free loan to the government. And really, who would want to do that? I am happy to report that this year, I’m receiving a whopping $350 refund. Perfection!

There is one big difference between 401(k) Match Day and getting a tax refund, though, and it could be quite significant to some. The difference is that if you receive your 401(k) match with every paycheck, that money goes into your 401(k) (duh), and if you adjust your tax withholding so you have less taken out for taxes each paycheck, that money goes into your bank account.

Why is this significant? You can’t touch your 401(k), but you can touch your bank account. That means if you’re the type of person who spends whatever money is available, you may be tempted to spend the additional money you’ll receive each month by altering your withholding. There are many people who look at their tax refund as one of their few opportunities to sock away some extra money. In that case, it’s worth losing out on interest because, well, they wouldn’t have gotten any interest in the first place because they would have spent the money!

Conclusion: Getting your 401(k) match in a once-yearly lump sum may be exciting, but it’s never in your best financial interest. Getting a large tax refund also may be exciting, and may be in your best financial interest if you’re the type who would not have saved it otherwise. However, I encourage everyone to live below their means and save as much as they possibly can out of each and every paycheck!

8 Responses to 401(k) Match Day

  1. I agree!! I do get excited about dividend payment day, interest payment day, and 401(k) contribution posting day and pay day though :) Mostly, I just like money appearing in my bank account and the sooner the better. My company matches my contributions at the same time as mine go in, unless I max it out early.

    • Gen Y Finance Journey

      Haha, that’s true. Any day when money appears in one of my accounts is a good day, I just want to have them sooner!

  2. My 403B is paid (they don’t match, they just give me 6% of my annual salary) monthly. I’d much rather be, “paid” monthly then yearly. Plus I’m curious what happens if you lose your job or take a new one before the match? I assume you don’t get anything?

    • Gen Y Finance Journey

      I’m curious about that as well. I may have to time my exit so it’s right after I receive my match for the previous year!

  3. Wow. I didn’t know this was a thing. Bummer. I mean, the match is great, but your company is less competitive in offering it in a lump sum, because as you said, you’re losing interest and the benefit of dollar-cost-averaging. I get mine every two weeks, and definitely enjoy it.

    • Gen Y Finance Journey

      I have complained a few times, but unless more of my coworkers complain as well, I doubt they’ll change.

  4. I always thought that was strange that at the previous company I worked for only deposited money once a year and I deposited 26 times. I was grateful for the match but I felt like i missed out on the gains that I would have gotten if they invested at the same time I did.

    • Gen Y Finance Journey

      At least I can take solace in the fact that my company isn’t the only one with this strange practice, though they are certainly in the minority. Companies are greedy in plenty of ways, but the least they could do is not be greedy in an area where most other companies aren’t being greedy!

Leave a Reply to KK @ Student Debt Survivor Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>